|
PARTICIPANTS'
CONTRIBUTION |
||
|
The Changing Faces of Racism New forms of stereotypical terminologies as tools for social stigmatisation and seclusion of minority groups. The case of Belgium and elsewhere. 1. Spring board: An attempt to trace the history of stereotyping can be a very hard nut to crack just as it is intertwined in the evolutionary history of humankind. In fact stereotyping exists in several forms and categories varying from one culture or society to another and with different magnitudes of consequences. Having a look at the general stereotyping of human beings, one notices a great variation in form and context in usage of the terminologies that spice or catalyse the usage to fully portray its intended meaning and expose the intended impact. The usage might not always nurse a negative intention though, but the usage itself is extremely volatile and might easily result to a negative stigma on a particular group of people. The difference between a stereotype and a concept is that a concept is mutable-it is reformed every time a new instance is encountered, and may be subject to alteration, broadening, subdivision, etc. A stereotype is fixed: the facts must be altered to fit it, not the other way around. A person with a concept of SWAN that is defined as "big white bird" will have to do some mental work when she encounters a black swan or a big white goose. A person with a stereotypical image of a swan won't recognized a black swan as a swan, and would never consider that a swan might be seen as in some ways similar to a goose. Stereotyping of human beings is a phenomenon that has been widely noticed in multicultural societies. In these very societies, there exist dialogical interplay of power games which result in enkindling the flames of prejudices, racism and in a rather general perspective, the "lord-vassal" subjugation relationship". Stereotyping human beings also
creates a situation of power assurance and the reconfirmation
of a polarised society. It is the reconfirmation of the unholy
"we" against the "they" parallel
or oppositions. The existence of negative stereotyping has impinged
horrible socio-economic, political and cultural chaos around
the world as we shall discuss further in this paper. Negative
stereotyping and its obvious consequences has forced many
groups of people to the margins of society under dire
psychological dysfunctions. The very first formal and recognised group of migrant communities appeared in Belgium in the late 50s. These groups were composed of Turkish, Italian and Moroccan economic migrants who flocked in at the time because of the shortage of workers in the huge mines in Belgium. The very first intentions both on the side of the host government and the migrants themselves were to return home after some years of delivered labour and services. But as the fate of history might be, most of these workers decided to remain and raise their families in Belgium. At that époque in history, they were tagged and identified as the 'Guest workers'. They all lived in designed and defined camps that could easily permit identification and classification. They lived in their own world defined by imported cultures and customs. Hardly was there an integration package for newcomers as designed by the modern system to integrate the migrants into the wider society and culture. Due to some internal dynamics
and differential social behavioural patterns within the "guest
workers", which of course were so strange to a 'Belgian',
direct identification and stereotyping began to emerge in the
form of nationality tags. e.g. the 'Italians',
for their boisterous nature, the 'Turkish' for their shrewd
attitude, and 'Moroccans' for their (as is claimed) culturally
imbibed violence and aggression. The first African blacks who formally set foot on Belgian soil came during the 1958 international expo in Brussels. Most of them were Zairians invited by king Leopold II, to demonstrate their exotic dances that some people had never seen before. It was some sort of human exposition. Some people came to see, touch and even smell the Black man. Of course, thousands of people came in from far and near just to have a look at the uncivilised and lost men of the dark continent who were flown in a special jet to perform their gyrating dances and displays. This international event paved the way for fluxes of more Zairians into Belgium. In the late 70s until the start of the 90s, there was a dramatic influx of migrants from Sub-Saharan Africa, including a reasonable migrant group from the horn of Africa. This number of migrants from the entire African continent almost quadrupled because of the African economic slum and political upheavals, wars and natural disasters of the 1980s till date. The need for more labour force in factories and other tertiary sectors, compelled the Belgian government to take positive steps to integrate the so called migrant communities into other job sectors other than the mines. Majority of these people were absorbed as labourers in Auto industries, building and construction sector, cleaning, etc. In this regard they were given longer but renewable stay permits. From this point onwards, a new terminology was derived or coined known as "the migrants". As time progressed most of the migrant families expanded. The children who were born in Belgium automatically had a Belgian nationality. They had Belgian education but were most often limited to low level professional schools such as catering, mechanics, and low level engineering. This new generation of the minorities could be considered more Belgian than foreign because they could fluently speak Flemish more than their parents' languages. They were deeply assimilated and versed with the Belgian culture. In this regard a new stereotypical terminology known as the "allochthone" was designed to describe this new generation. In recent political, social
discussions and debates the term allochthone is being used side
by side with the terminology 'the strangers' In this respect,
the strangers represent a wider group of minorities whose situation
is not yet defined by the communities in which they live. The
level of social interaction with the local community is very
superficial not giving enough room for their actual social status
to be identified. The second group of strangers is that of refugees/asylum
seekers whose application have been rejected or still pending
further hearings. These groups of people live in precarious conditions
with relatively little or no means of subsistence, housing and
clothing. A huge number of them squat with friends or are sealed
in asylum centres. In a very general terminology, these groups
of minorities have been called "les sans papiers".
(without papers). They stand the chance of being deported anytime
with or without notice. In opposition to allochthonous,
we have autochthonous. This term basically refers to a group
of people with a consolidated culture and history within a geographical
entity and still possessing those cultural values that uphold
their identity. We can cite some examples of autochthonous groups
to include the Amerindians (e.g Inuits), The Pachamamas of Latin
America, the pygmies of central Africa, the Mongols of Mongolia,
Hottentots of S.A, the aboriginals of Australia, to name but
a few. In Canada, the Inuits and other indigenous groups have been inhumanely subjected to what are called 'reserves, set up by the Canadian government as measures of protecting that specie of people and their culture before they finally disappear. As if human history has not taught us a lesson from the Apartheid experiences (where groups of people have been stereotyped as Blacks, whites, and coloured) the black/white racial tension in the US, the situation of the ROMA's in Europe, and of all, the holocaust of the 40s. The recent September 11 events
have plunged the whole world in a state of stereotyping each
other. The mere fact of being an Arab not to mention a
Moslem immediately subjects a person to some form of rejection
and social exclusion. Before the attack on Iraq, we did hear
of another political stereotype used by one of the worlds
biggest power mongers, as some nations and it's citizens were
described as belonging to the "axis of evil",
"uncivilised" "terrorist" etc. Stereotyping is a very common phenomenon in the United states of America just like anywhere else. Due to the complex nature of its history, the proceeding generations of Columbus's men invaded and overpowered the indigenes, almost wiping them out of the map of North America. In this case we see a typical situation where the quest for power and domination has been put in a persistent machinery. It bluntly depicts an ironical situation where the self-imposed white allochthone (now composing about 65.5% of the total population) has forcefully become the masters in the land of the autochthones (who barely make up 3% of the population). The second group of people
who make up the US population are those from Latin America tagged,
Hispanics, closely followed by the Black Americans.
The majority white population has claimed absolute power and
control over the whole country at the same time perpetuating
stereotyping-enhancing nomenclatures that do no good than denigrated
other groups. The majority whites classify some groups as Afro-Americans,
forgetting that they themselves can be classified as Euro-Americans.
If we have to analyse the two terminologies, we immediately notice
some form of subtle polarisation of the two groups. This stems
from the fact that the designated Black Americans (now
stereotyped as Afro-Americans) were formally categorised
as slaves, niggers, profiteers, and only fit to be treated as
secondary citizens or animals. etc etc. Hence, because of this
gruesome social categorisation stemming from marginalisation
or maybe marginalisation stemming from social categorisation,
socio economic and political disruption has been the incontestable
result. Many people have lost their lives and loved ones in the
struggle just to be considered as normal human beings able to
enjoy equal rights before the law. In Belgium, there is a greater incidence on someone from one of the minority groups to face constant police control and harassment, in some cases being locked up for having a stroll down street late at night or returning from the bar. My friend, Ahmed was brutally cut short of his romantic spree by the Brussels police as he and his "White" girl friend paraded down street hand in hand. He was kept 'for security reasons" in a cell, while the girl pled in anguish for her love to be freed. Instead She was politely put in a police van and escorted to her parents home. The minority groups that suffer from this wanton and unjustified controls are the Blacks, Arabs, Asian and Latin American communities. This perpetuation of violence and violation of the basic rights of the minority groups as humans, by the forces of law and order, leads me to question the basis of democratic principles and rule of law in a so called civilised world. There is a demonstrated and visible form of neo-barbarism strongly executed by the forces of law and order. A person of another skin colour
driving in a good looking second-hand car has just paved his
way for incessant police harassment and even negatives stir and
glances from the general public. In order to avoid attracting
negative attention from the public and rampant police checks,
many people of this category prefer to drive in old simple cars
to avoid being socially identified and brutalised. The situation
is gradually being revolutionalised within the youths to that
of provocation. The younger generations of the minority
groups have defied all the fears, driving in the latest versions
of the big cars, but at the same time, absolutely ready to mount
a fight with any one who challenges their right to a good
car and good living in general. The police themselves are
not excluded being challenged, not to talk of the jealous whites
who stir or make any open comment. Because of stereotyping many people other than 'whites' have been subjected to absolute fear insecurity and despair. Family bonds have been wantonly broken. Young girls and boys with another skin colour are getting frustrated even falling in love with partners of another skin colour because of the prejudices that surround the whole racial drama. These prejudices that stem from stereotyping have driven many people to cultivate a habit of introvertedness fearing to express emotions when the need arises. In the housing sector
in Belgium, every single person considered from a minority group
has faced brutal responses and rejection when in search of a
flat, room or apartment. From a personal survey, this whole existence
of stereotyping has led to what urban geographers have called
"urban decay". Minorities groups in Belgium can be
identified living in small clusters of shanty towns and slum
areas in the big metropolis. In other areas, houses can
be rented out to a "foreigner" only when they are in
dilapidating states or lacking basic internal facilities.
Most of the houses are those the white population are not ready
or never dream of living in. Foreign students also face dramatic
racial consequences when in search of rooms. In the university
city of Leuven, a student from India recounts how she called
the owner of an empty room she wanted to rent. The owner hearing
a foreign accent, uncompromisingly and rudely told her that the
room had been occupied. This Indian girl changed tactics, requesting
someone with a Flemish accent to help her out, the owner immediately
invited that 'voice' to come over for the contract. To his dismay
it was the Indian girl who signed the contract. He grumbled in
discontent and made her understand the contract would not continue
beyond six months! The situation has changed from a blatant "no"
of a few years ago to a subtle "rented out"
response we get nowadays from landlords. In order not to be tagged
a racist or to avoid some legal charges, some of the landlords
go the extent of telling you openly, we have nothing against
foreigners, but the rooms have been rented out, sorry!
There are cases of landlords directly telling visitors, 'we
don't rent out houses to foreigners'. In public transport especially in sub urban areas of Belgium, many minority groups do face segregation and isolation. The situation has changed from absolute to subtle form of segregation and isolation. The bus or train seat next to a black man, Turkish or Moroccan, Kosova or other East Europeans, can only be occupied when all the other seats have been occupied. When the vacant seats are at last occupied, the least eye contact in avoided. Their hand bags highly checked, strongly zipped and folded under the armsof course because the foreigners are considered the "smartest pickpockets". It can just be shear luck that an open minded person seats besides a foreigner before the bus/train gets full. A friends' wife once made a driving fault in high traffic jam down town Brussels. It didn't take two seconds for people to shower her with insults, "salle Maroccaine"(dirty Moroccan), but when they noticed she was a "white Belgian lady" they apologetically waved at her. In the school system in Belgium, racism plays a very great role in admitting kids from the minority groups. Some school authorities in Belgium claim that, admitting kids from such low backgrounds, degrades the standard of education and the image of the school itself. Parents who bring up kids for admission are often told that the chances are full and are instantly advised to check in other schools. The issue of racism or discriminative admissions in schools has aroused a complex political debate both at grassroots and at level of the Belgian parliament. There are a number of pressure groups and other NGOs, lobbying and pressing hard to reverse the situation such that children from minority groups can have the chance to better education like every other kid in Belgium. Recent facts and figures: During my last year graduate studies, we were about 30 in a class of many nationalities. Of the 30 students, there were about 15 Belgians including myself (only Black among the Belgians). During the final exam sessions in June of that year, only 3 of us succeeded. The rest had to redo the exams in September. When I started applying for jobs, I discovered it took me almost a year to have something doing, (not in accordance to my degree) meanwhile 12 of the other fellow Belgian mates had long secured jobs in the same area of specialisation as myself. The last became the first and the first became the last! In the job offices in Belgium,
a person identified as belonging to the minority group is often
subjected to high scrutiny and a series of detailed interviews.
First of all, you have to proof that your certificates are genuine
even when the logos of Belgian Universities are flashy enough
on them. The only ironical answer you get is, 'well done!
you are very smart and speak many languagesyou are very talented
and stand a very great chance of getting a job with us. ..But
can you come back next week because at the moment, the company
doesn't need people any more." Those who want to show
some sympathy may propose a cleaning job or a very mean job to
you irrespective of your string of university diplomas in front
of their noses. You may trod the path to the interim offices
until your shoes chop off, but "come back next time"
will be the simple and maybe eternal answer you getjust because
you are of another origins and skin colour other than white. The empirical question is, how can people from minority groups be taking their jobs when a non-white face can hardly be spotted in any public office in Belgium? Most of the jobs assigned to the foreigners are those mean jobs that very few Belgians would willingly want to do or out rightly refuse doing! People with other skin colours in Belgium have become unjust victims, scapegoats or culprits considered to be the sole perpetuators of socio economic malfunction! Amazing figures The research results further states that in Flanders the minority groups were discriminated against by 39% of the 181 vacancies investigated. In Brussels 34.1% of the 255 vacancies, in Wallonia 27% of the 201 vacancies. The mere fact of a foreign name suffices to be discriminated against in the job market. The level of racism in the
job market has gradually forced the minority groups to indulge
in informal strategies of survival. They operate large
businesses in "black", evading taxes to the detriment
of the Belgian economy. Rarely are there dealings with the banks
and other public financial institutions for fear of the sources
of their income being questioned or confiscated. Operating an
informal economy is the only means by which these people
are able to sustain their families both living in Belgium and
in their home countries or abroad.. Recent election results showed that the neo-nazist party is continuously growing both in its employed tactics and strength. From the recent federal and parliamentary results, it was noticed that the Vlaams Bloks' votes increased by a considerable margin compared to past elections. The results just confirmed the changing faces of racism which is gradually shifting from an open and direct confrontation, to a subtle, hidden and more hypocritical form. This subtle, hidden and silent form is more dangerous than open confrontational type because it renders it absolutely difficult applying concrete measure against. In the previous decades in Belgium, it was easy reading racist behaviours and feeling on people's minds and behaviours, but nowadays, everyone puts on a neutral face in boiling and anguished hearts. The tactics in the practice of racism are steadily changing, growing faster and getting more complex, than the available weapons to fight them. The federal government still
finds it a stumbling block in its political goals granting voting
rights to minority groups For the past years the Belgian
media has been propagating social aspects that may lead to deeper
racist feelings and hate. Crimes that involve foreigners are
immediately switched as headline news, making sure the origins
or skin colour of the person are clearly mentioned. The consequences
being that all foreigners are considered as criminals. What must
be clarified here is the fact that, when a West European (from
an EU member state) is involved hardly would there be pronunciations
of personal details and identity of the persons. And to achieve our set goals we must strictly adhere to the following points: Intensification of networking
with organisation tackling similar goals. Public awareness campaigns
at grassroots levels Intra/inter group solidarity We must learn to build faith and trust in each other just as Luther King says "with this faith we shall be able to transform our nation into jangling discords of brotherhood". Consulted sources: Emmanuel Berinyuy Ngaikpu "We must be the change
we wish to see" M.K.Ghandhi |
||